Incentives & penalties

UP Population Policy

By DrS.Saraswathi
(Former Director, ICSSR, New Delhi)

UP Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, launching the State’s Population Policy stated, “We should not forgetthat increase in population contributes to poverty in society. Hence, until all sections are made comprehensively aware, there will be a delay in fulfilling various goals”. The root of all major problems and prevailing inequality in society is believed to be in the rising population size. The CM touched a sensitive and controversial issue when elections are due in six months.
UP Population Bill(also referredto as Population Policy) aimsat enforcing two-child normand encouraging one-child family notsofar tried in any other State in India. China’s “one-child policy” with strict penal action for violationswas in forcebetween 1980 and 2016 for 36 years to arrest population growth, and was replaced by two-child policy which is now being changed to three-child policyto correct the demographic distortion of ageing population anddwindling working age-group.
Under the UP Population (Control, Stabilisation, andWelfare) Bill 2021, by adopting two-child norm, a couple will become eligible for a number of benefits including two special increments during their service, subsidy for purchase of a house, maternity or paternity leave with full salary and allowances for up to one year, and free healthcare and insurance coverage for the spouse, rebate on charges for electricity, water, etc., 3% increase in employer’s contribution to pension fund and such benefits.
Additional incentives will be extended to couples having one child only like four additional increments in salary, freehealthcare facilitiesand insurance coverage for the single child till the child turns 20 years of age, preference in admission ineducational institutions and free education up to graduation.
The Bill contains certain penal provisions also for violations. A person who will have more than two children after the law comes into effect would bedisqualified from applying to any government job, debarred from contesting elections to local bodies and would be denied the benefits of government welfare schemes. No ration card would have more than four units with not more than two children. Existinggovernment employees violatingthe law would be denied promotions.
Many States – Andhra Pradesh,Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha, Rajasthan, Telanganaand Uttarakhand — have adopted two-child policy in some form. SomeStates disallow themfrom contesting local elections.Haryana PanchayatAct which restrained people having more than two childrenfrom contesting panchayat elections was upheld by the Supreme Court.
Assam Chief Minister had a discussion a few days backabout the real threat posed by population explosion to economic development and decided to set up eight sub-groups to work for stabilisationof population by promoting two-child norm by revising eligibility criteria for various welfare schemes. The State with migrant Muslims and indigenous Muslims having different ideas on population management has to reach a consensus in the matter. Soon after taking oath as CM, he advised immigrant Muslims to adopt “decent” family planning measures.According to NFHS data, Assam’s fertility rate is 1.9 which isbelowthe replacement rate. Immigrant Muslims have also recorded sharp decline in birth.
But, the country has not adopted a national policy on family size and sticks to the Action Programme adopted at the International Conference on Population and Development 1994, which rules out any coercion or incentives and disincentives in implementing familyplanningprogramme.Assam and Gujarat have now announced a legislation on 2-child policy which provides a penalty for having third child.Rajasthan Health Minister has come out in support of UP bill though his party, Congress, views it as an anti-minority gesture. Karnataka isattracted by the proposed UP law.
Pre-election season is the ripe time for announcement of policies and promises that concern the entire population going to the polls. Uttar Pradesh, where Assembly election is due in about six months, is witnessing speeches and actions that will rouse everybody to realise thatpolitical masters have the power and authority to decide on matters which they have been believing to be in their hands.
Population policy is a matter of immense significance for development and welfare of people. Very few people are aware they can determine the size of their family by their own individual decision and the size of the population of a State or nation by collective decision onindividual family size. This has necessitated direct government intervention and has led to adoption of state policies and enactment of laws. Incentives,disincentives, preferences, denials, rewardsand penaltiesare instrumentsof enforcing population policy prescriptions of governments.Advanced nations have achievedstablepopulation notthrough compulsion of any law, but with the force of development.But they now face theproblem of ageing population.
UP CM, while launching theDraft Population Policy 2021-30coinciding with the World Population Day,statedthat the sole aim of the policy was to align the State’s reproductive rate to its development goals and that it was in line with the Sustainable Development Goals to be reached by 2030. The aim is said to be to ensure that resources reach everyone. The larger objective is to bring prosperity to the lives of the people and also reduce the infant and maternal mortality rate along with stabilising the population. He inaugurated PopulationStability Fortnight Programme starting from 11 July to draw people’s attention to the new Population Policy.
Fertility rate in UP, which was 3.8% a decade ago, is now 2.7% . In rural areas, TFR is 3.0% against 2.1% in cities due to level of development and education. The policy aims to bring down the reproductive rate to 2.1% by 2026 and 1.7% by 2030.Yogi Adityanath emphasised the need for “adequate gap” between two children which is necessary for maternal and infant/child health.UP has a populationexceeding 2crore. It is the most populous Statein India and the density of population is also high – 828 per while national average is 382 per
VHP is quick to reject the one-child ideaas a potential threatto Hindu community whose number will decline while Muslims will lag behind in adopting the policy.In Assam and Kerala, the TFR is below the replacement ratio of 2.1, but separately it is much higher for Muslims at 3.16 in Assam and 2.33 in Kerala. If the Bill is passed, it can alter Hindu-Muslim ratio in the state population in course of time.
VHP’s Acting President has pointed out that the law will increase dependency ratio as contracting population will upset working age population-dependent adults ratio.
TFR has been declining in the country and in the UP also.The declineis caused by economic growth, migration, education of girls, decline in infant mortality rate and not by official policy. Union Government also informed the Supreme Courtin response to a PIL that it is against any kind of coercion tocontrol population thatwould be counter-productive and lead to demographic distortion. — INFA